Amazing 20-Minute Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

Oh my goodness, are you having one of *those* days? You know, the kind where nothing sounds right unless it involves rich, melted chocolate hitting that creamy, unmistakable hazelnut flavor? When that craving hits, I don’t mess around with complicated stovetop custards or baking times. I head straight for this recipe because it is, without a doubt, the ultimate, easy, no-bake Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe You Must Try Today. If you love my classic Oreo cheesecake, you are going to absolutely swoon over this.

I’ve made a ton of desserts over the years for parties, but this pie always disappears first. It’s my emergency go-to, especially when company shows up unexpectedly! My secret? It’s the texture—it’s ridiculously light but still holds that intense Nutella punch. Trust me, you need this in your baking arsenal, and the best part is you don’t even have to turn on the oven. We’ll have this beauty chilling in about twenty minutes!

Why This Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe Is a Must-Make

Seriously, I call this pie my savior for last-minute dessert emergencies! It ticks every single box when I need something that screams decadent but whispers, “I made zero effort.” This recipe is gold because it’s completely no-bake, which means instant satisfaction—well, almost instant satisfaction once it chills!

• It’s incredibly rich without being heavy. That chocolate hazelnut swirl is everything!
• Zero oven time means less heat in my kitchen during the summer.
• The entire active prep takes maybe twenty minutes tops. So fast!

If you need something fast, check out my caramel pumpkin dip—it’s another winner!

Speedy Assembly for Your Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

Look, the total time might say over four hours, but don’t let that fool you! That’s the mandatory waiting game. You only have about 20 minutes of actual work. You’re just whipping cream, mixing cheese, and folding. That’s it! The rest of the time is just the fridge doing the heavy lifting to set this dreamy filling.

Gathering Ingredients for Your Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

Okay, this is the easy part! Because this pie is so fast, you don’t need a massive grocery run—most of this is probably already hiding in your fridge or pantry. The absolute MVP here is that pre-made graham cracker crust. I mean, who has time to make a crust from scratch when the filling is this good?

You’ll need eight ounces of cream cheese, and make absolutely sure it’s softened! If it’s cold, you’ll just end up with lumps, and nobody wants a lumpy Nutella dream, right? Oh, and that heavy whipping cream? It has to be cold. Ice cold! That’s how we get those beautiful stiff peaks.

We’re also grabbing powdered sugar—not granulated, powdered, please! And of course, vanilla extract to deepen the flavor. If you’re exploring other goodies, I highly recommend checking out how I use peanut butter when I make my oatmeal cookies; the same principle applies—using the right texture of binder is everything!

• One 9-inch graham cracker crust (pre-made!)
• 1 cup of heavy whipping cream (cold!)
• 8 oz cream cheese (softened only!)
• 1 cup powdered sugar
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• 1 whole cup of Nutella
• About 1/2 cup of thawed whipped topping (like the stuff in the tub)

Essential Equipment for the Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

Even though this is a no-bake pie, you still need the right tools so you don’t accidentally deflate all the air you’re working so hard to whip into things! Don’t worry, it’s nothing fancy, but having these items ready makes the 20 minutes of prep fly by.

First thing, you absolutely need an electric mixer—handheld or stand mixer, either works! Trying to beat that heavy cream by hand until stiff peaks form is a cardio workout I never signed up for. You’ll need at least two good-sized mixing bowls, too.

• Electric Mixer: For whipping the cream and beating the cream cheese until it’s silky smooth.
• Two Large Mixing Bowls: One for the base cream, one for the Nutella mixture.
• Rubber Spatula: This is your best friend for folding. Remember, we want gentle!
• Measuring Cups and Spoons: Precision keeps this pie stable!
• The Star: Your 9-inch graham cracker crust, ready to go.

That’s really all you need! Have your spatula ready right next to the bowl when you start folding in that gorgeous whipped cream. It prevents that moment of panic when you realize you need to wipe your hands and grab a tool!

Step-by-Step Instructions for the Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

Alright, this is where the magic happens! Keep your movements calm and gentle from here on out, because we’re incorporating a lot of air, and we want that air to stick around. We’re not baking this, so structure comes entirely from how well we whip and how gently we combine things.

First things first, start with the whipping cream. Pour that ice-cold heavy cream into a clean bowl—it needs to be totally grease-free, or it won’t whip right. Use your electric mixer and beat it until you see stiff peaks forming. What does that mean? It means when you pull the beaters out, the peaks stand straight up without flopping over. If you see waves or droops, keep going! This is the skeleton of your pie.

While that’s happening (or after you set it aside), you tackle the cream cheese mixture in the other bowl. Beat the softened cream cheese, powdered sugar, and vanilla until it’s completely smooth. Nobody wants a chunk of cold cream cheese hiding in their dessert, so I always scrape down the sides really well here. Then, gently fold in your cup of Nutella until it’s just combined. Don’t go crazy mixing it—we’re just incorporating the flavor for now.

Whipping the Cream Base for the Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

Remember what I said about stiff peaks? This is the key to making sure your pie sets up firm enough to slice cleanly. If your cream is too soft, the finished pie will weep or slump right out of the crust. If you aren’t sure, lift your whisk straight up; if the peak holds its shape like a little mountain, you’re golden! Set that bowl aside; you earned a small taste test for quality control!

Creating the Flavorful Nutella Filling for Your Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

Now for the folding part—this is where most people accidentally deflate their pie structure. Take about a third of that stiff whipped cream and gently fold it into your Nutella-cream cheese base. I mean *gently*. You’re trying to lighten the heavy base before adding the rest. Once that first batch is incorporated, slowly fold in the remaining whipped cream until you see no white streaks left. Stop mixing right when it’s uniform!

Spoon that glorious filling carefully into your graham cracker crust. Then top it with your thawed whipped topping. Now, the hardest part: hiding the pie away in the fridge for at least four hours. Longer is better if you can stand it! This resting time allows the cream cheese and whipped cream to work their magic and firm up. It truly transforms into a sliceable, decadent pie. If you want to see some other stunning ways to finish a dessert, check out my pistachio cake recipe—the presentation ideas there are fabulous!

Tips for Success with Your Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

This no-bake pie relies so much on technique and temperature control, even though it feels super simple! If you follow these little secrets, you’ll guarantee a pie that sets up beautifully, tastes incredible, and doesn’t slide off the plate when you serve it. The biggest key here is treating that whipped cream right—don’t overmix it after it goes into the Nutella base!

If you’re feeling adventurous or maybe ran out of graham crackers (oops!), remember the notes mention you can absolutely swap that crust out. A chocolate cookie crust, like crushed Oreos mixed with butter, is my next favorite choice. It doubles down on the chocolate element, which is never a bad thing in my book! When you’re looking for inspiration on creative finishes, I always look at how people handle textures—it reminds me of the layering I do when making my button cookies.

Also, here’s a little tip about your Nutella: if it came straight out of the fridge, it might be a little stiff. I sometimes microwave my measured cup of Nutella for just ten or fifteen seconds—just enough to make it gloriously soft and easy to fold into the cream cheese without dragging down the texture.

Nutella Cream Pie Recipe Garnish and Presentation Ideas

You’ve waited four hours, and now it’s time to serve! Presentation matters, even for a ridiculously simple pie like this. The final layer of whipped topping really gives you a beautiful canvas.

The recipe notes mentioned chopped hazelnuts, and honestly, you *have* to do this. Toasting the hazelnuts for just five minutes in a dry skillet before chopping them makes a huge difference in flavor. Sprinkle those crunchy little guys right over the whipped topping. They add texture contrast and really emphasize that wonderful chocolate-hazelnut flavor profile.

For the cleanest slices, this is critical: use a long, sharp knife. Before every single slice, dip your knife into a tall glass of hot water—seriously, hot water!—and then immediately dry it perfectly with a paper towel. That hot, clean blade slides right through the chilled filling without dragging or making a mess. Trust me, this trick turns a sloppy piece into a restaurant-worthy slice every time!

Storage and Make-Ahead Guidance for the Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

Since this gorgeous Nutella cream pie is totally no-bake, storage is all about keeping that filling firm and fresh! The chilling process isn’t just about letting the flavors blend; it’s what actually turns our fluffy mixture into a sliceable dessert. You absolutely need that minimum four-hour chill time, but honestly? If you let it sit overnight, it will be even better.

When you finally put it in the fridge, you have to cover it. If you just toss a piece of plastic wrap right over the top, you run the risk of it sticking to that lovely white topping. My trick is to lightly spray a piece of plastic wrap with cooking spray, and then drape it over loosely so it doesn’t touch the surface. Alternatively, if you have a pie carrier or a cake dome, use that! That keeps any accidental smells from fridge leftovers out of your perfect dessert.

This pie keeps beautifully in the refrigerator for about three to four days. The crust might soften just a tiny bit after day two, but honestly, my family never lets it last that long! If you’re making this ahead for a party, it’s fantastic to assemble it the day before. It gives the flavors extra time to deepen, and it means you aren’t scrambling right before guests arrive. It reminds me of how ahead of the game I can get when I bake the Honey Wheat Bread—prep work always saves the day!

The most important thing is that it needs to stay cold. If you plan on taking it out to sit on a buffet table, don’t leave it out for more than about an hour, because we don’t want that beautiful whipped cream losing its structure. Keep those leftovers tightly covered and cold, and you’re set!

Frequently Asked Questions About the Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe

I know sometimes when a recipe seems this simple, you just have a few little nagging questions floating around. Don’t worry about it! Since this is a no-bake dessert, people usually wonder about structure and stability. I’ve gathered the questions I get most often about making this perfect cream pie! If you are looking for something savory while you wait for this beauty to chill, you might check out my broccoli cheddar soup adaptation!

Can I make this Nutella cream pie ahead of time?

Absolutely, yes! In fact, I highly recommend it. While the minimum chilling time is four hours—which gives you a sliceable dessert—this pie really shines after it sits overnight. The longer it chills, the more those flavors meld, and the firmest your structure will be. I usually aim to have it completely assembled and tucked into the very back of the fridge about 12 hours before I plan on serving it. Just remember to cover it well so it doesn’t absorb any weird fridge smells!

What if I don’t have a graham cracker crust for this pie recipe?

Oh, that’s an easy fix! If you don’t have a pre-made graham cracker crust on hand, don’t panic! Swapping the base is simple. As I mentioned earlier, my second favorite option is using a chocolate cookie crust—think Oreos or any chocolate wafer. Just crush them up really finely and mix them with a few tablespoons of melted butter until the crumbs hold together when squeezed. Press that mixture firmly into your pie plate and chill it for about 15 minutes before adding the filling.

If you’re feeling super ambitious and skip the store-bought shells entirely, you could even whip up a quick crust using toasted pecans or walnuts mixed with a sticky binder like maple syrup and a touch of melted coconut oil. Just make sure whatever crust you choose takes up enough volume on the bottom of the pie plate!

Estimated Nutritional Snapshot for This Cream Pie

Okay, let’s be real for a minute. This pie is pure indulgence! We’re talking rich cream cheese, glorious Nutella, and a sweet crust. If you were looking for a low-calorie snack, well, you definitely clicked on the wrong recipe, and that’s okay! Sometimes you just need a treat, and this pie is worth every single bite.

I always keep these numbers handy just so I have a general idea, but they are just estimates because, let’s face it, the exact brand of Nutella or the fat content of your heavy cream can change things slightly. This breakdown is based on dividing the whole pie into 8 generous slices, which is how I usually serve it. If you cut smaller wedges, the numbers go down, but who does that with pie?

If you are cutting servings smaller or just looking for amazing ways to boost your energy earlier in the day, you should check out my guide to high-protein breakfast options—that’s proper fueling!

Here’s the quick snapshot per serving (1 slice):

• Calories: Around 450—That sounds about right for a chocolate hazelnut powerhouse!
• Total Fat: About 28 grams (Yes, that includes the delicious saturated fat, sorry not sorry!)
• Total Carbohydrates: Roughly 48 grams
• Sugar Content: About 45 grams (It is a dessert, after all!)
• Protein: A humble 6 grams

Keep this pie chilled until the absolute last minute, and enjoy it in moderation—unless it’s a special occasion, then go ahead and have two slices! You deserve it after all that whipping and folding!

Share Your Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Creations

And just like that, we’re done! Isn’t that the best? You’ve made the quickest, most decadent, show-stopping dessert that required zero time standing over a hot stove or waiting for an oven to preheat. My absolute favorite part of sharing these recipes—especially standouts like this Irresistible Nutella Cream Pie Recipe You Must Try Today—is hearing from you all.

Seriously, I want to know how it went! Did your whipped cream get stiff peaks on the first try? Did you swap out the crust for chocolate cookies? Tell me everything in the comments below. Knowing how you made this pie yours means the world to me.

If you loved this recipe and it saved your dessert plans, please hit that 5-star rating button at the top of the post! It really helps other home cooks find this easy, delicious pie. I’m already dreaming about what to bake next, and I promise to keep sharing the easy, no-fuss wins!

If you’re looking for another guaranteed crowd-pleaser that uses a similar structure of light cream filling and a solid crust base, you absolutely have to try my banana cake with cream cheese frosting sometime. It’s got that same “wow” factor without the fuss!

Keep that pie chilled, slice it carefully using the hot water trick, and enjoy every single bite. Happy baking—or should I say, happy *no-baking*!

Print